Muslim India headlines
  1. Hope to get justice now: Pathribal victim’s son
  2. 'Murder': SC cites AFSPA, lets Army choose what kind of trial
  3. Maulana Abul Kalam Azad: THE MAN WHO KNEW THE FUTURE
  4. Face covering prohibited in Manglore College
  5. Mosque demolished in Rajasthan, Waqf Board blames Imam
  6. Indian Muslims Still Paying the Price of Partition
  7. ‘Centre ignoring Muslim freedom fighters’ : JUHind
  8. Hyderabad: Hindu Vahine activists triggered riots, Four arrested
  9. Syed Ghulam Akber Engineer is no more
  10. Fact finding Report on Communal Violence in Hyderabad
More Muslim India headlines
World headlines
  1. Iran, big powers agree to keep talking
  2. West to target Iran's nuclear fuel work
  3. Developing Economies Ready to Check Bluff of Developed World
  4. Iran cuts oil to Greek firms over payment problems: Report
  5. US bents: No Iran oil-import sanctions for Japan, 10 EU nations
  6. Israel attack killed over two dozen civilians in Gaza
  7. Netanyahu Says U.S. and Israeli ‘Clocks’ Differ on Iran’s Threat
  8. Obama warns Israel against ‘Loose Talk of War on Iran"
  9. Lady Tonge resigns Lib Dem party whip over Israel remarks
  10. India Asserts Against US Israel Effort to Name Iran in Delhi Terror Attack
More World headlines
Nation headlines
  1. 'Cops fanning Islamophobia'
  2. Fissures within NDA over presidential candidates
  3. Sachar, Mishra, Harsh Mander, yet the Silent Budget of 2012 ...... and our inaction
  4. Seeking legal opinion to free blast accused: UP CM
  5. Saffron extremists hurl meat on temple to trigger riots, four on run, one arrested
  6. Kashmir report rules out ‘simple return to pre-1953 situation'
  7. CCS may be briefed on Kashmir interlocutors report on Thursday
  8. Narendra Modi tops negative votes in global poll
  9. FRANKLY SPEAKING : Arms lobby planted the story
  10. SC spreads its media gaze from court to crime to contempt
More Nation headlines
you are here: Home /
 

SWAMINOMICS: Why are mass graves in Kashmir so passé?

By SWAMINATHAN S ANKLESARIA AIYAR
Updated Sunday, 28 August 2011 16:08:38 - IST (UTC +5:30)

The Jammu & Kashmir State Human Rights Commission says 2,730 bodies have been found in unmarked graves in Kashmir. This officially confirms earlier accusations by human rights groups. Security forces once claimed any such graves were those of unidentified militants killed in military encounters. But the commission says 574 bodies have already been identified as those of local villagers, and DNA tests will expose many more. This was mass murder.

Most countries would have treated this as major news, but our media barely noticed. Bored with unending tales of human rights violations in Kashmir, our media saw Anna Hazare’s fast and even Aishwarya Rai Bachchan’s pregnancy as more newsworthy.

Two decades of insurrection in Kashmir have eroded our ability to feel horror, to be nauseated by mass murder. Yes it’s terrible, most people say with a shrug, but it’s all Pakistan’s fault and we can’t surrender to jihadis.

As a libertarian, i dislike ruling people by force, and am dismayed by the parallels between India’s independence struggle and the Kashmiri azaadi struggle. Basharat Peer’s “Curfewed Nights” and a new collection of writings from Kashmir “Until My Freedom Has Come”, highlight Kashmiri humiliation and anger against what they call Indian colonial oppression.

Actually, India has not colonized Kashmir. Rather, it has tried to integrate Kashmir with itself. Nation building is a difficult task that, across the world, has required a mixture of persuasion and firmness. Using this mixture, India succeeded in integrating some regions with secessionist movements — Tamil Nadu, Mizoram, Punjab. But 64 years of this approach have manifestly failed in Kashmir. Using ever more force begins to look like colonial oppression more than attempted integration.

Kashmiri alienation flows from Muslim revolts against the erstwhile Dogra ruler, rigged elections after 1947, and security forces guilty of torture, killing and rape in the name of national security. The Kashmiri insurrection has taken 70,000 lives of civilians, armed forces and militants. Some are due to terrorism, some to genuine defence against jihadis and armed infiltrators. But the mass graves bear testimony to horrors against innocent Kashmiris too.

Secular Indians feel outraged by 900 Muslim deaths in Gujarat’s 2002 riots. They are outraged by the killing of 3,000 people by Chilean dictator Pinochet. But they are mostly bored by 2,730 Kashmiri bodies in unmarked graves.

It’s all the fault of Pakistan and jihadi terrorists, say some. True, Pakistan trained many jihadis. But many of these were Kashmiri youngsters angered by Indian outrages. They were killed in droves by Indian security forces, and their flow to Pakistan greatly diminished. There was no Pakistani training or inspiration behind the thousands of youngsters who took to the streets during the Srinagar intifada last year. They did not seek union with Pakistan. They simply wanted Indian “killers” off their soil.

Many analysts emphasize the legalisms of Kashmiri accession to India. But hundreds of Indian princes had legal treaties with the British Raj, which our independence movement declared irrelevant after the rise of Indian nationalism. Liberal values cannot be based on legalisms alone.

Let us forget legalisms and hold a plebiscite, which we promised anyway in 1947. Probably the valley will vote for azaadi, with Jammu and Ladakh opting for India. We should see this not as a loss of territory but a gain of moral stature, and return to the liberal values that drove our independence movement.
Most Indians say a plebiscite will wreck Indian secularism and let loose another round of partition killings. Really? If India was so wedded to secularism, it should never have accepted partition along communal lines in 1947. Having agreed to communal partition, it was hypocritical to violate this norm in Kashmir.
In Junagadh in 1947, a Muslim Nawab ruling over a Hindu majority, acceded to Pakistan. India refused to accept this, ousted the Nawab forcibly, and justified this by holding a plebiscite that went overwhelmingly in India’s way. If this was a secular tactic, why call a similar plebiscite in Kashmir a danger to secularism?
Critics of a plebiscite claim that a vote for azaadi will trigger fresh partition riots, targeting Muslims throughout India. Really? Is supposedly secular India actually so communal that Hindus will slaughter Muslim innocents galore, with the state a helpless bystander? I have a better opinion of India than that.

Forget what Kashmiris demand. Let us allow self-determination in Kashmir to cleanse our own hands and hearts. This will not mean surrender to militants or Pakistan. It will mean returning to the liberal values of our independence movement, which are getting tainted beyond recognition by the mass graves in Kashmir. We need to regain our capacity to feel horror.
(Curtsy: TOI)

Tags: SWAMINATHAN S ANKLESARIA AIYAR Un-marked graves in Kashmir, 2500 un-identified bodies buried, State Human Rights Commission, Investigation Team

  • 'Cops fanning Islamophobia'

    MUMBAI: The last time Muslims and Dalits created a joint political platform in Maharashtra was in the 1980s. Led by former smuggler and don Haji Mastan, the Dalit Muslim Suraksha Mahasangh (DMSM)...

    2012-05-07 17:11:22 |
    0 comments
  • RDX not used in 13/7 blasts, but found in...

    MUMBAI: Chemical analysis of a powder-like substance collected from a Byculla apartment where two suspected Pakistani 13/7 bombers stayed has proved that it is the deadly explosive RDX. The...

    2012-05-03 17:34:23 |
    0 comments
  • Hope to get justice now: Pathribal victim’s son

    Srinagar : For Abdul Rashid Khan, it has been a long wait for justice. Twelve years after his father Juma Khan was allegedly picked from his house, killed in a fake encounter and dubbed a foreign...

    2012-05-03 17:30:23 |
    0 comments
  • 'Murder': SC cites AFSPA, lets Army choose what...

    New Delhi : The Supreme Court gave the Army full “discretion” to choose between a court martial and a criminal trial for seven officers accused of killing five persons in an encounter in...

    2012-05-03 17:27:07 |
    0 comments
  • Syed Ghulam Akber Engineer is no more

    New Delhi. Syed Ghulam Akber, member Markazi Majlis-e-Shoora (Central Advisory Council) and former Secretary Jamaat-e-Islami Hind breathed his last at Care Hospital in Hyderabad at about 1 p.m....

    2012-04-30 20:38:08 |
    0 comments
  • Fact finding Report on Communal Violence in...

    Government responsible for Communal Violence in Hyderabad city RSS outfits Communalizing the situation and polarizing population by developing Communal Sentiments. Introduce and pass Communal...

    2012-04-25 11:01:25 |
    0 comments
  • Chisti released from Ajmer jail

    Picture: Pakistani scientist Khalil Chisti talking to the media after his release from jail in Ajmer on Wednesday. Ajmer: After spending over 14 months in jail, 80-year-old ailing Pakistani...

    2012-04-11 19:38:23 |
    0 comments
  • SC grants bail to Pakistani doctor Chisty

    New Delhi, The Supreme Court Monday granted bail to Pakistani doctor Mohammad Khalil Chisty, who is undergoing life imprisonment in a jail in Ajmer for involvement in a clash that resulted in the...

    2012-04-09 20:06:17 |
    0 comments
  • How the US uses sexual humiliation as a political...

    Believe me, you don't want the state having the power to strip your clothes off. And yet, it's exactly what is happening. Bagram airbase was used by the US to detain its 'high-value' targets...

    2012-04-09 17:40:46 |
    0 comments
  • Dara Singh Encounter, BJP leader blocked every...

    Jaipur: The Dara Singh conspiracy did not end with the fake encounter on October 23, 2006, but continued for weeks afterwards, the CBI believes. Sources in the agency said that they had evidence...

    2012-04-07 14:16:24 |
    0 comments
  • Dr. Chishty released from jail, deported to...

    New Delhi : The Supreme Court was told Monday that Pakistani virologist Mohammad Khaleel Chishty, undergoing life term in Ajmer jail for murder, has been deported Pakistan, his home after he was...

    2012-03-20 17:40:58 |
    0 comments
  • No Immunity in Rape and Murder Cases Under AFSPA:...

    New Delhi: It is now a well established fact that State Apparatus of India is lethargic and insensitive in the cases of Human Rights violations. However Courts play an important role to push in right...

    2012-02-05 12:25:10 |
    0 comments
  • India fails to check human rights violations:...

    NEW DELHI: Custodial killings, police abuse including torture, and failure to implement policies aimed at protecting vulnerable communities marred India's record in 2011, according to the Human...

    2012-01-29 18:56:03 |
    0 comments
  • SWAMINOMICS: Why are mass graves in Kashmir so...

    The Jammu & Kashmir State Human Rights Commission says 2,730 bodies have been found in unmarked graves in Kashmir. This officially confirms earlier accusations by human rights groups. Security forces...

    2011-08-28 16:54:38 |
    0 comments
  • Graves and Graves, all un-marked: More than 2500...

    It is now official that more than 2500 un-identified bodies are buried in four Northern Districts of Kashmir. It is feared that the numbers may be many fold if un-marked graves are also reported from...

    2011-08-28 16:46:52 |
    0 comments
  • A truth panel can find answers to unmarked...

    Srinagar : Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah said here today that a “Truth and Reconciliation Commission is the only way to find answers” to “who have been buried in these...

    2011-08-24 00:35:02 |
    0 comments
  • Extra judicial killings in Kashmir: 2156...

    Srinagar : For the first time in Jammu and Kashmir, an official inquiry has said that it is “beyond doubt” that there are scores of unidentified bodies in unmarked graves in the Valley — as...

    2011-08-21 18:54:10 |
    0 comments
  • Menace of Extra Judicial Killings

    Killing in custody, in fake encounters and in police firing has become a regular feature of Human Rights Violations in the country but no serious effort is in sight to deal the menace. Extra judicial...

    2011-08-21 12:04:58 |
    0 comments
  • Sarfraz Shah killing: Karachi court awards...

    KARACHI: The Anti-Terrorism Court (ATC) announced its verdict in the Sarfaraz Shah killing case Friday, Geo News reported. According to the verdict, Rangers official Shahid Zafar who shot Sarafaraz...

    2011-08-13 13:02:17 |
    0 comments
  • U.S. Drone Attacks: 168 children killed in...

    Islamabad: As many as 168 children have been killed in drone strikes in Pakistan during the past seven years as the CIA has intensified its secret programme against militants along the Afghan...

    2011-08-12 00:09:46 |
    0 comments